The Longest Running Magic Show on Long Island
The Parlor of Mystery is a place where the magic happens close up and right in front of you. Each show is a different parlor magic show with a new line-up of magicians from near and far. At the Parlor, you’ll see experienced prestidigitators as well as young, up-and-coming conjurers. It’s modern. It’s funny. It’s grown-up. And, it’s for grown-up audiences.
Many people consider the term “parlor” to be old-fashioned and think parlor magic is magic performed long ago by gentlemen in top hats and long coats in the living rooms of the privileged. And at one time it was exactly that. But today it means magic that is intimate, that doesn’t require expensive, large-scale stage equipment, and is performed close to the audience and without a stage.
The Parlor of Mystery is just that, a place where the magic is performed right in front of you. It’s modern. It’s funny. It’s grown-up. And it’s for grown-up audiences.
The Parlor of Mystery is a monthly magic show that is different every month. Every show features a new line-up of magicians from near and far. The goal of the Parlor is to showcase the talents of some of the region’s best magicians as well as introduce visiting magicians to the Long Island community. Expect to see accomplished prestidigitators as well as up-and-coming conjurers.
Read about us in this article from Vanish Magic Magazine. Click on the graphic below.
Looking for the perfect way to spend a magical Sunday morning with the family? The Silly Sorcerer’s Showcase is a high-energy, laugh-filled variety show featuring some of Long Island’s top family entertainers! Join us at Theatre Three for an unforgettable experience packed with magic, comedy, and circus fun.
This show is designed for kids of all ages—and their grown-ups! Whether you’re a fan of magic, juggling, or just good old-fashioned silliness, this is one event you don’t want to miss.
Bring the kids, bring the grandparents, and get ready to giggle, gasp, and cheer. The Silly Sorcerer’s Showcase is pure family fun—and a little bit of magic—right in the heart of Port Jefferson.
Magic Jeff (Jeff Miller)
With over 25 years of experience performing for families, schools, and special events, Jeff Miller is one of Long Island’s premier magicians. Known for his fun, fast-paced shows and amazing sleight-of-hand, Magic Jeff brings a unique combination of magic, humor, and audience participation that captivates children and adults alike.
Jeff’s interactive performances are full of surprises, and his enthusiasm is infectious. He’s entertained thousands and continues to be a favorite among families and kids’ organizations throughout the region.
Greg Milstein – Circus Juggler Extraordinaire
Greg Milstein is a world-class circus performer, juggler, unicyclist, clown, and more. With over 30 years of professional experience performing in 25+ countries, Greg brings a dazzling circus energy to the stage. He’s also the Executive Director of the National Circus Project, a nonprofit dedicated to circus arts education.
Greg’s act features high-energy juggling, balancing stunts, and physical comedy that will keep your eyes wide and your jaws dropped. His contagious energy and circus flair are the perfect complement to the magic and mischief onstage.
Mike Maione – The Silly Magician
The name says it all—The Silly Magician delivers nonstop laughs and magical mischief. Mike Maione is a family magic specialist who blends classic illusions with a lovable, over-the-top personality. His routines are packed with comedy, visual gags, and plenty of chances for kids to help out on stage.
Mike’s mission is simple: make kids laugh while amazing them at the same time—and he succeeds every time.
Get ready for an unforgettable evening of mystery and amazement! Haunted Encounters—a spine-tingling magic show starring the astonishing Mike Maione and the enigmatic Judge Gary Brown—will take center stage at Theatre Three in Port Jefferson on Halloween night. This one-night-only event blends mind-blowing magic with eerie storytelling for a night that’s equal parts thrilling and fun. Don’t miss your chance to witness the unexpected—join us for Haunted Encounters and make this Halloween truly magical!
Judge Gary Brown
Judge Gary Brown is a distinguished United States District Judge for the Eastern District of New York. Beyond the courtroom, he’s an accomplished author and creator within the magic community—his works include The Coney Island Fakir, a celebrated Al Flosso biography, and Wandcraft: Making and Using a Magic Wand.
Yet it’s his magic and storytelling that truly shine. Performing since age seven, Judge Brown has invented striking illusions like the Viking “Spirit Trumpet” and “Telekinetic Chess,” and his mentalism skills have been showcased on Penn & Teller: Fool Us. As a sleight-of-hand innovator, he expertly weaves narrative into his acts—his routines often use historical or paranormal themes, with the magic wand serving as both prop and storytelling device. Judge Brown combines legal precision with theatrical flair to create performances that captivate both the mind and the imagination.
Mike Maione
Mike Maione is a highly skilled magician and mentalist based on Long Island, with more than two decades of experience creating unforgettable performances. What sets Mike apart is his mastery of bizarre, paranormal-style illusions that blur the line between sleight of hand and supernatural phenomena. He’s renowned for eerie mind-reading feats—like predicting hidden choices or revealing long-forgotten thoughts—and uncanny manifestations performed in dim candlelight, invoking true otherworldly atmosphere . His creations often involve experimental elements—pendulums, tarot, vanishing messages—designed to immerse audiences in mysterious storytelling that pushes conventional magic into chilling new territory.
Theatre Three
412 Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
631-928-9100